Monday, October 8, 2018

Hardness of heart. October 7, 2018 The Rev. Kathleen M. Sturges




Mark 10:2-16, Genesis 2:18-24

Divorce.  Likely everyone gathered here today has been affected by it.  Either we are people who have divorced or we love people who gone through a divorce.  Even marriages that have remained intact often have at least one story of struggle where divorce was weighed as an option.  But there are other ways to handle difficulties that arise in marriage.  Once when Ruth Graham, wife of the famous preacher, Billy Graham, was asked if she ever considered divorce she innocently replied, “Divorce?  No.  Murder, yes.”

“Is it lawful for a man to divorce his wife?”  This is the question the Pharisees pose to Jesus in our gospel today.  Let me just say here that a superficial read of Jesus’ response has caused way too much pain and suffering to the people who have needed God’s grace the most. Now everyone around Jesus knew the answer to the Pharisees’ question.  The law of Moses allowed a man to write a certificate of dismissal and divorce his wife.  Jesus doesn’t bother to quibble with this.  Instead he goes straight to the heart of the matter.  "Because of your hardness of heart,” Jesus explains, “Moses wrote this commandment for you.”  And he goes on to reference the act of creation and relationship where the two become one flesh and declares, “Therefore what God has joined together, let no one separate.” 

It’s important to remember that marriage in first century Palestine was quite different than marriages of today.  Back then marriage was not a choice between individuals, but an arrangement between families, in particular the men in the families.  Marriage was a tool to ensure economic stability and social privilege.  A woman’s body was treated as property belonging first to her father and then to her husband.   Debate within Jewish circles of the time was not about if a man could divorce his wife but how - under what circumstances was it lawful.  One popular teaching coming out of the scribal school of Hillel gave the man complete impunity.  He could divorce, or dispose of, his wife for any reason at any time.  While the Shammai school limited divorce to cases of adultery.   In a world where women had no legal protection and were totally dependent on their husbands’ support, the prospect of divorce put women at great risk.  Given this reality, Jesus’ prohibition against divorce puts him on the side of the weak and the vulnerable providing some degree of protection for the women of his time from men who might use divorce for their own benefit. 

Fast forward roughly two thousand years and, at least in most industrialized countries, things have changed greatly.  Marriage has become less about gaining security and more about people seeking mutual fulfillment.  Taking Jesus words out of their cultural context and uncritically using them as an unbreakable command against divorce denies the spirit of care and concern that pervades this text.  Not to mention we miss the real point that Jesus is trying to make.  As is often the case, Jesus is not so concerned about the state of the law, but the state of the heart.
 
Divorce isn’t really the issue here.  It’s a symptom of a much more serious problem - that problem being hardness of heart.  And it’s not just married or divorced people who suffer from such hardness.  All of us, to some degree or another, do.  Regardless of our marital status, if we have known division and separation in a relationship we have experienced divorce in our lives.  Yes, hardness of heart splits up marriages, but it also divides parents from children, brothers from sisters, Republicans from Democrats, Christians from Muslims, whites from blacks, rich from poor.  This type of separation goes beyond having differences with one another it’s about coming to the point where one has no need for the other. 

But before it comes to this, before any type of a relationship ends in that final kind of division or divorce, separation begins first in the heart - either in our own or in another’s.  We start by isolating ourselves.  We put up emotional walls and hunker down.  Often we become fearful or defensive or judgmental.  We do things and think things that close ourselves off.  Now given the wide range of relationships that we have in our lives sometimes this type of hardness is absolutely necessary for safety and survival.  There are certain situations where we have to harden ourselves for the sake of protection in order to find freedom from toxic or dangerous relationships.  But God knows that living with a hard heart for an extended period of time is not a long term solution that brings life.   

You know what the first thing that is ever said to be not good in the Bible?  Being alone.  We hear that in our first reading today from the book of Genesis.  After all of creation is declared good, God goes onto say, “It is not good for man to be alone.”  Now that doesn’t mean that alone time is bad or that God intends everyone to be married.  But it does reveal that God’s intent is for human beings to be in relationship with one another - to experience relationships that are deeply connected and meaningful.   Hardness of heart works against all this.  It takes a soft heart, a heart that is open and vulnerable to be able to live into the abundance of God’s creation.

And one of the means that God uses to soften our hearts is worship.  Do you feel it sometimes?  You come into church after a long, difficult, maybe even painful week.  But you’ve held it together.  You’ve been strong.  You’ve kept it going.  But then you’re here and your defenses are down, which gives God’s Spirit an opportunity to minister to you.  To speak to your heart.  To whisper into your soul that you are loved.  This is the holy work of softening.  And for many of us it results in tears.  Which sometimes, people have told me, is the very reason they avoid church - because they are afraid they will cry.  But I say come.  Church is a place where we are surrounded by the love of God and God’s people.  Let the softening of your heart happen here.     

Still, there’s no getting around that we live in a broken world full of imperfect people.  We break promises, we let each other down, we hurt one another, often without even meaning to.  And Jesus is in the midst of such chaos offering us his life and peace.  It is a soft heart that is able to receive that gift and to be joined with God in the deepest places of our being.  When we do we become “one flesh” with God.  And what God has joined together no divorce will ever separate.   

No comments:

Post a Comment