Monday, June 4, 2018

Failure is part of the plan. June 3, 2018 The Rev. David M. Stoddart



2 Corinthians 4:5-12.

According to an old church legend, after Jesus ascended into heaven, the first one to greet him was the great Archangel Michael, a glorious prince among angels and captain of the heavenly host. He said, “Lord, you have accomplished marvelous things. What will you do now? What will happen next?” Jesus replied, “I have entrusted my mission to my friends and followers. They will be my Body in the world and carry on my work of salvation.” But when he said this, a shadow passed over Michael’s face and he looked troubled. He thought of Judas betraying Jesus, and Peter denying him. He thought of that fragile community of weak and fallible human beings. And he asked, “But, Lord, what if they fail?” And Jesus said, “I have no other plan.”

I don’t mean to sound insulting or anything, but you might think that the Lord of the Universe could come up with a better plan than us. I mean, seriously. For centuries before the birth of Jesus, the ancient Israelites failed over and over again to live as God called them to live, and for the past two thousand years, the Christian Church hasn’t done much better. All too often in our history, the Church has supported slavery, violence, and discrimination. All too often, the Church has favored the wealthy over the poor, and made peace with oppression. Christian voices are all too often associated with judgment, condemnation and exclusion, rather than love, mercy, and inclusiveness. And even apart from the big issues, individual churches are composed of very imperfect people who can be difficult and uninspired. So we could be pardoned for thinking that maybe this is not the best plan to save the world.

Except, apparently, it is — at least in God’s eyes. Jesus actually demands that we rethink all of our notions of success and failure. He himself was born poor, spent lots of time with the outcasts and losers of his society, was hated by the establishment, and eventually executed as a criminal, dying a horrible and humiliating death on the cross. This is not the way we define success, and yet every week we gather under that cross and celebrate the fact that Jesus’ failure saves the world. And although it takes a different form, his Body the Church constantly lives with failure as well. No one understands this better than the Apostle Paul, the one who aided and abetted the murder of Christians before he literally saw the light. Paul is a flawed man, and the Corinthians he writes to are flawed people, and God uses them anyway. In his first letter to them, he teaches them that God’s foolishness is wiser than human wisdom. And in his second letter to them, which we read from today, a letter which wrestles painfully with Paul’s limitations and their limitations and all the ways they exasperate each other, Paul reminds them that we have this treasure in clay jars. We are imperfect vessels of grace. But that is not because we have failed to follow the plan: failure is part of the plan. And until we really know that, we cannot fully experience the Good News of Jesus Christ.

The life and death of Jesus, the letters of Paul, the witness of the saints all point us to the same shocking conclusion: we only experience God’s love in the midst of our flaws and failures, not in spite of them. And that is the way God wants it to be! Too many religious people think the opposite: they think if they can just get everything right, then they’ll get God. If we are successful in our careers, have our 2.3 above average children, live in our beautifully kept homes, give money to worthy charities, attend church every week, and don’t commit any serious sins, THEN the heavens will open and God will smile and rain down blessings upon us. Not so, says the Crucified Lord. Not so, says the sinner Paul. Grace is only amazing because it comes to us when we are limited and imperfect, because the only perfection that matters is the love of God at work in our world, embracing all of us as we are: But we have this treasure in clay jars, so that it may be made clear that this extraordinary power comes from God and does not come from us. As flawed as Paul and those Corinthian Christians were, God did amazing things with them and through them. So rather than make futile attempts to be perfect and thus earn God’s love, we are encouraged to receive God’s love as we are — and then let that love do whatever it’s going to do in our lives, trusting that it will do marvelous things.

Thomas Keating, a Trappist monk and teacher of prayer, puts it this way: “God seems to want to find out what it is like to live human life in us, and each of us is the only person who can ever give him that joy. Hence our dignity is incomparable. We are invited to give God the chance to experience God in our humanity, in our difficulties, in our weaknesses, in our addictions, in our sins. Jesus chose to be part of everyone’s life experience, whatever that is, and to raise everyone up to divine union.”

So we can’t hide behind our unworthiness. Yeah, we may have fought with our spouse, yelled at our kids, or treated our co-workers poorly. We neglected people who were hurting and we overlooked injustice. Each one of us has messed up this week in one way or another, probably many ways, maybe badly. And yet the love of God is still seeking to be incarnate in each one of us, still seeking to bless us and bless others through us. Forgiveness is the heart of the Gospel, and transforming love is the power of the Gospel. If that were not the case, I couldn’t get up and preach today or any Sunday. So the question is not “Am I worthy?” or “How can I earn this?” The question is rather “Will I accept this? Will I say yes?” Will we say yes to the love of God moving within each one of us right now? The only real failure would be to say no, because if we say yes, we cannot ultimately fail, no matter how many times we stumble and fall. The love of God that Jesus reveals will be made manifest in this world through us because God wills it. It may be crazy, it may take forever, but that is the plan. And there is no other plan.

No comments:

Post a Comment